Bill Description: Senate Bill 1269 (S1269) reworks Idaho’s cloud seeding code by clarifying the Idaho Resource Board’s authority and establishing reporting and public meeting requirements.
Rating: -1
Does it create, expand, or enlarge any agency, board, program, function, or activity of government? Conversely, does it eliminate or curtail the size or scope of government?
Senate Bill 1269 enlarges the scope and function of government by formalizing and institutionalizing cloud seeding as an ongoing state-authorized activity. While the Idaho Water Resource Board already exists as a constitutionally recognized entity under Article XV, Section 7 of the Idaho Constitution, and its duties are established in Idaho Code 42-1732, 42-1733, and 42-1734; SB 1269 expands its operational role. By codifying cloud seeding as a defined state program with funding authority, regulatory oversight, enforcement mechanisms, and structured reporting, SB 1269 transforms what may be a narrower or locally coordinated activity into a formalized, continuing governmental function.
(-1)
Does it in any way restrict public access to information related to government activity or otherwise compromise government transparency, accountability, or election integrity? Conversely, does it increase public access to information related to government activity or increase government transparency, accountability, or election integrity?
Senate Bill 1269 modestly increases transparency and accountability in the conduct of cloud seeding operations. Although the bill expands the Board’s authority, it also creates some procedural safeguards through public meetings and reporting that help hold government accountable to the people.
It is important to note that the Board already conducts meetings which already allows for public comment. This bill simply clarifies in statute that cloud seeding programs be discussed and conducted through public meetings held in accordance with Idaho’s open meeting law (Title 74).
SB 1269 further codifies annual published reports containing operational data, monthly reporting by authorized operators, disclosure of materials used and methods employed in cloud seeding activities, and public discussion of environmental impacts.
(+1)
Does it violate the spirit or the letter of either the United States Constitution or the Idaho Constitution? Examples include restrictions on speech, public assembly, the press, privacy, private property, or firearms. Conversely, does it restore or uphold the protections guaranteed in the US Constitution or the Idaho Constitution?
While SB 1269 offers some clarifications and safeguards to the existing cloud seeding program, the program in itself is still unconstitutional. Laws allowing the intentional dispersal of chemical agents into the atmosphere without explicit, individual informed consent raise bodily autonomy concerns and can impinge on property rights, as individuals cannot opt out of exposure or seek redress for harms in most circumstances due to liability coverage language. This is an explicit violation of inherent rights protected under Idaho’s constitution, Article I, Section 1, in which all Idahoans have rights of “enjoying and defending life and liberty, acquiring, possessing and protecting property, and prosecuting harms to those rights.” SB 1269 legitimizes state authority for activities that affect individuals’ environment and property without consent or recourse.
(-1)
